# Candidate submittal best practices for staffing recruiters

> Candidate submittal best practices for agency recruiters: what to include, a copyable summary template, how many to send, and how to track results.

Source: https://deephire.com/blog/candidate-submittal-best-practices
Last checked against the product: 2026-11-19

## Key takeaways

- Send a short written case with every resume that maps the candidate to the client's must-have requirements.
- Confirm pay, availability, start date, and written right to represent before anything goes to the client.
- Submit three to five strong, screened candidates per job order instead of a large stack of maybes.
- Name any gap up front so the hiring manager trusts the rest of your summary.
- Track submittal-to-interview ratio by client and by recruiter to see whether your submittals are landing.

Candidate submittal best practices come down to one goal. Give the hiring manager enough evidence to say yes to an interview without calling you first. In practice that means sending fewer, better-matched candidates, each with a short written case tied to the job order, confirmed pay and availability, written permission to represent them, and some proof of the skills the client cares about most.

Plenty of decent candidates get turned down for a simpler reason than fit. The recruiter forwarded a resume with a one-line note, and the hiring manager had to guess why it mattered.

## What is a candidate submittal?

A candidate submittal is the package a recruiter sends to a client or hiring manager to put a candidate forward for a specific job. At a staffing agency it is the handoff between your sourcing and screening work and the client's decision about whether to interview.

Treat it as a recommendation with your name on it, not a forwarded resume. Clients notice which recruiters read their job orders closely and which ones send anyone whose title matches, and they decide how much attention your next submittal gets based on that.

## What should a candidate submittal include?

Use this as a checklist before you hit send. If you cannot fill a row, you are not ready to submit.

| Element | What to include | Why the client cares |
|---|---|---|
| Match summary | Two or three sentences on why this person fits this role | Lets a busy manager decide in under a minute |
| Must-have check | Each requirement from the job order with evidence | Shows you read the order, not just the title |
| Pay or bill rate | Confirmed expectation, in the format the client uses | Prevents a dead offer at the end |
| Availability | When they can start and which shifts or schedule they can work | Contract and hourly roles often hinge on this |
| Location and logistics | How they get to work and whether onsite or remote suits them | Avoids early no-shows and drop-offs |
| Reason for looking | One honest sentence | Helps the manager judge retention risk |
| Interview availability | Two or three windows in the next week | Cuts scheduling back-and-forth |
| Resume | Clean, consistent format, contact details handled per your agreement | Looks professional and protects your placement |
| Screening evidence | Scorecard notes, skills test result, or recorded answers | Gives proof beyond what the candidate wrote about themselves |
| Right to represent | Confirmed in writing, dated | Protects you if the candidate appears from another source |

On screening questions, ask only what you are allowed to ask where the job is located. Rules on topics like salary history and background checks vary by place, so check with your legal team before you add a new question to your intake.

## How to write a submittal summary hiring managers will read

The summary is the part most recruiters rush, and it is the part most managers read first. Keep it under 200 words and write it for someone reading on a phone between meetings.

### Lead with the match

Open with the single strongest reason this person fits, not a recap of their whole career. If the client said the hardest part of the role is managing a night crew, start there.

### Map to the must-haves

List each requirement from the job order and the evidence for it. Evidence means something specific, like a certification with an expiry date or the size of the team they managed. Avoid adjectives like strong or great unless a fact follows them.

### Point out the gap before the manager finds it

If the candidate is missing something, say so and explain why you are submitting anyway. When a manager discovers a gap you left out, they start reading your other summaries with suspicion. When you raise it yourself, it shows you screened the person carefully.

### Put pay and start date at the end of the summary

Finish with pay and the start date, then add the interview windows on the last line. These are the details that kill deals late, so put them where nobody can miss them.

### A submittal template you can copy and fill in

- Subject: [Job title] submittal: [Candidate first name], [one-line hook]
- Why this person: [two or three sentences tied to the client's biggest need]
- Must-haves: [requirement]: [evidence], one line per requirement
- Gap: [what is missing] and [why it is manageable or how they would close it]
- Pay: [confirmed expectation or rate]
- Start: [date or notice period], [shift or schedule fit]
- Reason for looking: [one sentence]
- Interview windows: [two or three options]
- Attached: resume, [scorecard, skills test, or recorded answers]

Here is a filled example for a warehouse shift supervisor role, using a hypothetical candidate:

> Why this person: She has run a second shift of about twenty pickers for three years and owns the shift's safety reporting.

The must-haves come next. Her forklift certification is current through next year, and she uses a warehouse management system daily. She is also bilingual in English and Spanish. For the gap, she has not run cycle counts herself, but her current site does them and she supports the lead who runs them. The logistics lines close it out.

If your team uses a shared scoring sheet, attach the scores. Our guide on building an [hourly candidate scorecard](https://deephire.com/blog/hourly-candidate-scorecard) has a template that drops straight into a submittal.

## How many candidates should you submit per job order?

For most roles, three to five well-screened candidates make a good slate. With fewer than three, the manager has nothing to compare against. With more than five, you are handing them screening work that was yours to do. High-volume hourly orders call for bigger counts, but the standard is the same. Send only people you would defend on a call.

You do not always need to hold out for a full slate. If you find a clear fit on day one, send that person and tell the client more are coming. Strong candidates get other offers while you wait to bundle them. Agree on this with the client at intake so a single early submittal does not read as a thin search.

## How fast should you submit after getting a job order?

Aim for a first credible submittal within one to two business days on contract and hourly roles, and within the first week on harder permanent searches. Speed matters because clients often give the same order to more than one agency, and the first good candidate sets the bar.

Speed only helps if the candidate holds up. A fast submittal that gets rejected costs you more trust than a slower one that gets an interview, so the answer is to screen faster, not to skip screening. One way to do that is to send a short recorded pre-screen right after the first call, which lets you check communication and role knowledge without booking another call. Our [staffing video interview workflow](https://deephire.com/blog/video-interview-workflow-staffing-desks) walks through that process from job order to submittal.

## Get the right to represent before you send anything

Never submit a candidate without written permission for that specific client and role. Many recruiters accept a text or email reply that names the client, the job, and the date. What counts as proof can depend on your client agreements and where you operate, so check with your legal team. Save the permission in your ATS with the candidate record.

This protects you in two ways. The candidate knows where their resume is going, so a call from the client will not surprise them. And if another agency or the client's own job board brings in the same person, you have a dated record. Before you ask for permission, search your database for duplicates, which is much easier if you keep up with [candidate database hygiene](https://deephire.com/blog/candidate-database-hygiene).

## Common submittal mistakes that get candidates rejected

- Sending a resume with no summary, or a summary that repeats the resume.
- Submitting someone whose pay expectation is well above the budget and hoping the client stretches.
- Leaving out a known gap that the manager finds in the first interview.
- Using a different format for every candidate, so the client cannot compare them side by side.
- Submitting someone who has not confirmed interest in this specific role.
- Pasting in keywords from the job order instead of evidence.
- Sending candidates in a slow trickle with no word on how many more are coming.

## How to show evidence beyond the resume

Resumes are self-reported. Clients trust submittals more when they can see or hear something the candidate did. Options include skills test results, your scorecard ratings, reference notes, and short recorded answers to two or three role-specific questions.

Recorded answers work well because the manager hears the candidate explain their own experience in their own words. In DeepHire, you can share a shortlist with a client by link, and the viewer does not need an account to watch. Keep the clips short and pick questions that match the client's must-haves instead of generic ones.

## How to measure whether your submittals are working

Track a few numbers per client and per recruiter. Definitions for these are in our [recruiting metrics glossary](https://deephire.com/blog/recruiting-metrics-glossary).

| Metric | How to calculate it | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Submittal-to-interview ratio | Submittals divided by first interviews | Whether your summaries and matching land |
| Interview-to-offer ratio | First interviews divided by offers | Whether your screening predicts fit |
| Time to first submittal | Days from job order to first submittal | Whether you are first in line |
| Rejection reasons | Tally the reasons clients give | Where your intake or screening is missing something |

A submittal-to-interview ratio of 4:1, for example, means four submittals for every first interview. Lower is better, and the trend for each client tells you more than any single month.

Ask for a rejection reason every time. If one client keeps rejecting on pay, your intake call missed the real budget. If another keeps rejecting on communication, add a recorded screening step for that account.

## What to do after you submit

Call or message the hiring manager within a day to confirm they received the submittal and ask when they will review it. If you hear nothing in two to three business days, follow up with one new piece of information, such as an updated availability window, instead of a bare check-in.

Keep the candidate informed at the same pace. Tell them when you submitted and when you expect to hear back. Candidates who hear nothing from you tend to start taking other recruiters' calls.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is a good submittal-to-interview ratio for recruiters?

It varies a lot by role and by how well you know the account, so compare yourself against your own history rather than a universal target. If the ratio is getting worse for one client, look at their rejection reasons first. That usually points to a gap in intake or screening.

### Should I include the candidate's contact information on a submittal?

Follow the terms in your agreement with the client. Many agencies remove direct contact details so all scheduling runs through the recruiter, which protects the placement. Whatever you choose, apply it the same way to every candidate.

### Can I submit the same candidate to two clients?

Yes, as long as the candidate agrees to each submittal in writing and knows which companies have their resume. Tell the candidate if one process moves faster so they can make an informed choice. Check first whether the candidate has already applied to a client directly before you submit them there.

### How long should a candidate submittal email be?

Keep the written summary under about 200 words, plus the attached resume and any screening evidence. The manager should be able to decide on an interview from the summary alone. Anything longer usually gets skimmed or skipped.

### What should I do if a client never responds to a submittal?

Follow up once or twice with something new, such as updated availability or a competing offer timeline. If the silence continues, ask directly whether the role is still open and whether your candidates are on target. If a client goes quiet often, raise it at your next account review.
