Benefits of asynchronous video interviewing for recruiters, and how to get them
The benefits of asynchronous video interviewing for recruiters, plus a worked time example and a five-step plan to roll it out without losing candidates.
7 min read
Key takeaways
- Asynchronous video interviews mainly save recruiters scheduling time and let you hear from every qualified applicant, not just the few you can phone.
- Ask every candidate the same three to five questions and score them against a rubric you write before you watch.
- Keep the interview short enough to finish on a phone, and send reminders so candidates actually complete it.
- Use async video for first-round screening, then move strong candidates to a live conversation.
- Record your completion rate and time from application to shortlist before you switch, so you have something to compare against.
The main benefits of asynchronous video interviewing for recruiters are time and reach. You stop scheduling first-round calls, and you can hear from every qualified applicant instead of only the few you had time to phone. Candidates answer the same questions when it suits them, and hiring managers get a few short videos to watch instead of a page of your notes. There are tradeoffs, mainly that you can't ask follow-up questions, and they're covered further down along with a rollout plan.
If you are new to the format, start with this plain definition of an asynchronous video interview. In short, you set the questions and the candidate records answers on their own time, so nobody has to be on a call at the same moment.
What are the main benefits of asynchronous video interviewing?
Most of the gains land on the recruiter, but candidates and hiring managers notice some of them too.
| Benefit | What changes for you | Who notices first |
|---|---|---|
| No scheduling for first rounds | No calendar back and forth to book screens | Recruiter |
| Faster review | Watch at faster playback and stop early on clear mismatches | Recruiter |
| Same questions for everyone | Side-by-side comparison instead of scattered phone notes | Recruiter and hiring manager |
| Candidates pick the time | Evening and weekend completions, no time off work needed | Candidates |
| Easy sharing | Hiring managers watch answers instead of reading your summary | Hiring managers and clients |
| A record of the screen | You can revisit exactly what was said | Your team |
| Screening scales | Fifty applicants take the same setup as five | High volume teams |
The scheduling and review rows are the ones you'll feel in the first week. The others build up as you run more roles through the same setup.
How much time does async video save a recruiter?
It depends on your volume and how you screen today, so run the numbers with your own pipeline. Here is an illustration.
Say 30 applicants pass your resume check for a customer support role. If each phone screen runs 15 to 20 minutes, that's 7.5 to 10 hours of calls before you count the emails and texts it takes to book each one, or the no-shows you have to rebook. Spread across a normal workday, that can eat most of two days.
With an asynchronous interview, you write three questions once and send one invite to all 30. If each answer runs one to two minutes and you watch at 1.5x speed, a full interview takes a few minutes to review. You can also stop after the first answer when someone isn't a fit. In this example, the same 30 candidates could fit into a morning.
The bigger change is when the work happens. Phone screens chop your day into 20-minute blocks around other people's calendars. Async review can be batched into one or two focused sessions, which leaves the rest of the day for sourcing and client calls.
Why candidates find async interviews easier to finish
Phone screens ask candidates to be free at a time you pick. Async video lets them record when they are ready, which is often late at night or on a weekend. Shift workers don't have to step off the floor to take your call, and people in other time zones are not stuck with awkward slots. Retakes help nervous candidates who would otherwise be stuck with a stumbled first answer. And because the link opens in a phone browser, there is nothing to install.
Reminders help a lot too. DeepHire, for example, sends two automatic reminders, about 2 and 3 days after the invite, and reports about a 97% interview completion rate. Whatever tool you use, keep the interview short and tell candidates up front how many questions there are and roughly how long it will take.
Does asynchronous video make screening fairer?
It can, if you set it up with structure. When every candidate gets the same questions, in the same order, with the same time limit, you compare answers to answers. That beats comparing one relaxed phone conversation with one that got squeezed between meetings.
Do this work before you watch anything.
- Write a short rubric for each question, describing what a strong, acceptable, and weak answer sounds like.
- Have two people score the same candidates for the first batch and compare notes.
- Score the content of the answer, not the candidate's room or camera.
- Offer another format, such as audio-only questions or a phone call, for candidates who ask for an accommodation.
Recording and storing candidate video raises legal questions, and AI scoring adds more. The rules vary by state and country. Tell candidates who will watch their answers and how long you keep them, and check with your legal team before you roll out. For accommodation questions, see these ADA hiring basics for recruiters.
How do video shortlists help with hiring managers and clients?
With a written screening summary, the hiring manager has to take your word for it. With a short video shortlist, they can watch the answers and judge for themselves. That usually cuts down on "can you tell me more about this one" emails and speeds up decisions on who moves forward.
Agencies can do the same with clients. Send three strong candidates with their best answers and your notes, and the client can watch on their phone between meetings. In DeepHire, a shortlist can be shared by link and viewers do not need an account, so a busy manager has one less reason to put it off.
Two habits make sharing work better. Add one line per candidate explaining why you picked them. And keep the list short. A manager can watch three candidates in one sitting, while a list of twelve tends to sit unopened.
Where asynchronous video interviewing falls short
Async video is a screening tool, not a replacement for every interview. Plan around these limits.
- There is no back and forth. You cannot ask a follow-up question in the moment, so save probing for the live round.
- Some candidates dislike recording themselves. Keep it short and explain why you use it.
- Senior or passive candidates may expect a conversation first. For those roles, a call can come before the recording or replace it.
- Weak questions give weak answers. "Tell me about yourself" tells you little in 90 seconds.
- Every extra question is another chance for a candidate to quit partway, so treat five as a ceiling.
- Candidates with poor connections or older devices may struggle, so test the link on a phone yourself.
How to roll out async video interviews in five steps
1. Pick one role to start
Choose a role with steady applicant flow and a clear first-round screen, such as support, sales development, or hourly roles. Run it there for a few weeks before expanding.
2. Write three to five questions tied to the job
Each question should map to something on your scorecard, like availability, a core skill, or how the person handles a common situation. For a starting point, pull from these pre-screening interview questions and what each one tells you.
3. Set the candidate experience
Pick a time limit per answer, often one to three minutes. Allow retakes. Give a deadline of three to five days and set up reminders. Write a short invite that says how long it takes and who will watch.
4. Agree on the rubric and review routine
Decide what a strong answer sounds like before invites go out. Block two review sessions a week on your calendar so interviews do not pile up.
5. Share, then move to a live round
Send your top candidates to the hiring manager with a note on each. Book live interviews only for the people who earned them.
How to measure whether it is working
Pick a few numbers and record them before you switch, so you have something to compare against. If you need formulas, this recruiting metrics glossary has worked examples.
| Metric | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Interview completion rate | Whether candidates finish what you send them |
| Time from application to shortlist | How much faster you get candidates in front of managers |
| Recruiter hours spent on first rounds | Where the saved time actually goes |
| Shortlist to live interview rate | Whether managers agree with your picks |
| Hiring manager response time | Whether video shortlists get decisions faster |
If completion is low, shorten the interview and rewrite the invite. If managers reject most of your shortlist, go over the questions and rubric with them. The screen is probably measuring something different from what they care about.
Frequently asked questions
What are the disadvantages of one-way video interviews?
You can't ask follow-up questions, and some candidates feel awkward recording themselves. Long interviews and vague questions also hurt completion and give you little to judge, so keep it to three to five focused questions.
How many questions should an asynchronous video interview have?
Three to five questions is a good range for a first-round screen. With a time limit of about one to three minutes per answer, the whole interview takes candidates around 15 minutes or less.
Do candidates like asynchronous video interviews?
Many like recording on their own schedule without taking time off work, especially shift workers. Others prefer a live conversation, so explain why you use the format and offer another option if someone asks for an accommodation.
Can asynchronous video interviews replace phone screens?
For many high volume and early-stage roles, they can replace the first-round phone screen. Keep a live interview for later rounds, and consider a call first for senior or passive candidates who expect a conversation.
Is it legal to record candidate video interviews?
Rules on recording consent and video storage vary by state and country, and AI scoring brings its own questions. Tell candidates up front that they are being recorded and how long you keep the videos, and check with your legal team before you start.